WD Purple or Seagate Skyhawk?

[Owen_B_NZ]

One of my TiVos has the dreaded Error S03 and after multiple Kickstart 57 and retries have decided to
replace drive with new WD Purple 1TB but those drives are no stock.
Has anybody tried the Seagate Skyhawk 1TB, it appears to be a very similar spec?

I have WinMFS and a Sata adaptor for my USB socket ready to go, but would appreciate
advice on Seagate before proceeding.

Thanks all

Owen B (now in Caboolture)

[Owen_B_NZ]

Well, nobody knows about the Seagate so I used WinMFS in Admin mode to back up TiVo#3 then wrote that backup onto the faulty drive.
Just a few hours of clear and delete everything, re-run Guided Setup and the drive is, for now, happy. The crunch will be the next update session

We will see.......

[Owen_B_NZ]

Well, I could not just sit and wait, wrote the good backup onto the Skyhawk and away we went, all good, mounting holes
all match up, easy as peeing shells. I will probably retire the WD320 Green and just leave the Skyhawk in there for long term
and still have a spare HDD. So, for the price (unbelievable) I vote the Skyhawk.
Also figured out a cure for the constant rebooting at 2am of both Tivos, just do the update at 7am so the sorting is not upset
by the 2am reboot, all good.

[tenty]

Any update on Seagate working?

Unsure if this is a bad attempt at a troll, but as Owen kindly pointed out, the Seagate is working. Given that I believe the problem's been solved out I'm going to lock the thread. Thank you Owen for at least answering your concern and contributing back, it's appreciated and I hope others will find the information useful.

[StephenWoods]

Any update on the Seagate working?

[Owen_B_NZ]

Replied your PM but for everyone else: Yes the Seagate Skyhawk is running well and very quietly. WinMFS recognised it OK and 200/400 hours are available.
Considering upgrading spare Tivo but no need for now. You do need a good backup to save doing the C&DE where you lose everything.