WD Purple or Seagate Skyhawk?

[Owen_B_NZ]

Well, I could not just sit and wait, wrote the good backup onto the Skyhawk and away we went, all good, mounting holes
all match up, easy as peeing shells. I will probably retire the WD320 Green and just leave the Skyhawk in there for long term
and still have a spare HDD. So, for the price (unbelievable) I vote the Skyhawk.
Also figured out a cure for the constant rebooting at 2am of both Tivos, just do the update at 7am so the sorting is not upset
by the 2am reboot, all good.

[tenty]

Any update on Seagate working?

Unsure if this is a bad attempt at a troll, but as Owen kindly pointed out, the Seagate is working. Given that I believe the problem's been solved out I'm going to lock the thread. Thank you Owen for at least answering your concern and contributing back, it's appreciated and I hope others will find the information useful.