Quote:
This one upset me cause the second tivo (the one which had the problem first) has a new seagate 254(?)GB drive. It shouldn't be dead.
There's no such thing as "shouldn't" as I've had a few that give up soon after purchase. It happens sometimes, and in no way unusual or limited to just Seagate hard disks. I would not be too upset because if it is a new hard disk then just follow the procedures on the Seagate website to get a warranty replacement as it will have a 5 year replacement warranty. The Seagate website will show you what you need to do to initiate a return and even allow you to print out the necessary paperwork and shipping labels.